10 worst ‘The Boys’ characters, ranked
10. A-Train (early seasons)
In the earlier seasons, A-Train was frequently ranked among the most disliked characters due to his arrogance and disregard for consequences. His involvement in Robin’s death and subsequent actions only reinforced that perception. Although later developments have added complexity to his character, his early behavior continues to define his place on such lists.
9. Ryan (middle seasons)
Ryan’s portrayal has been more divisive than outright negative. During certain phases, his shifting loyalties between Homelander and Butcher led to frustration among viewers. However, his circumstances as a child caught between conflicting influences have led many to view him with more understanding, placing him lower on the list compared to others.
8. Madelyn Stillwell
Madelyn Stillwell is widely remembered as one of the show’s most unsettling antagonists. Her composed and empathetic exterior masks a deeply manipulative approach, particularly in her influence over Homelander. Their dynamic plays a key role in shaping his trajectory, while her indifference toward collateral damage underscores her negative perception.
7. Little Nina
Little Nina is recognized as a formidable character, but her storyline has received mixed reactions. Her subplot, largely separate from the central narrative, is often viewed as a distraction. Her treatment of Frenchie and Kimiko, reducing them to tools for her own goals, has made her an easy target for criticism.
6. Robin Ward
Robin occupies a complicated place in the narrative. While clearly a victim and gone within seconds of introduction to the show, her role is often seen as limited to motivating Hughie’s journey in toppling the 'heroes.' Repeated flashbacks and hallucinations have led some viewers to view her presence as overused, occasionally slowing the momentum of the broader storyline and being unnecessary.
5. Alastair Adana
As the leader of the Church of the Collective, Alastair Adana is frequently viewed as a manipulative figure hiding behind a polished image. His exploitation of characters like The Deep and A-Train for influence and control has been widely criticized. His corporate-spiritual rhetoric adds to the frustration, making his eventual exit a memorable turning point.
4. Blue Hawk
Blue Hawk stands out as a particularly controversial figure, representing a type of character who masks harmful behavior under the guise of heroism. His town hall appearance, which escalates into a violent outburst, is often cited as one of the most uncomfortable scenes in the show. His refusal to acknowledge wrongdoing further cements his negative reception.
3. The Deep
Despite being a source of dark comedy, The Deep remains one of the most criticized characters in the series, given his rather disturbing 'love' with an octopus that fans and audiences alike have called 'unnecessary.' His repeated attempts at redemption rarely lead to meaningful change, reinforcing the perception that he never truly learns from his actions. His need for validation and lack of conviction continue to make him ridiculed, disliked, and, of course, the most hated.
2. Firecracker
Firecracker quickly became a polarizing addition, designed as a satire of toxic media culture. Her personal vendetta against Starlight and her tendency to turn sensitive experiences into content have made her widely criticized. Rather than a traditional supervillain, she comes across as a relentless provocateur, which many viewers find particularly grating. Not to mention, the entire disturbing relationship she created with Homlander in 'Dirty Business.'
1. Todd
Todd is often regarded as one of the most disliked civilians in the series, largely because his behavior feels so grounded in reality. Over time, he shifts from a mild-mannered stepfather into a staunch Homelander supporter who even cheers for a public humiliation. His smug attitude, particularly while creating distance between Mother’s Milk and his daughter, makes his presence especially frustrating for viewers.
